WHAT is the DIFFERENCE between a HYDRAULIC and a MECHANICAL DISC brake?
Both systems work well, but each has its own quirks depending on whether the bike is for the city, the mountains or the road. The answer depends on how the bike is used and on the rider. The advantages of hydraulic brakes are more braking power and less hand fatigue for the rider. The advantages of mechanical brakes, on the other hand, are lower weight and less maintenance, meaning fewer trips to the bike workshop.
If you like the content of these videos ⏩⏩⏩ RIDE with us on YOUTUBE ⏪⏪⏪
Which is better: mechanical or hydraulic disc brakes?
Mechanical brakes work with a cable that tightens or slackens when you pull the brake levers, just like conventional non-disc brakes. When the cable tightens, the caliper closes and the pads slow the disc. Hydraulic brakes, as their name suggests, have a hydraulic circuit: inside the housing there’s no cable but a fluid, an oily liquid similar to the one in car brakes. When you pull the lever, the oil moves along the hose to the caliper, where it pushes the pads against the disc so they rub and slow the bike. So in a mechanical disc brake system, the pressure on the lever acts through a steel cable that pulls the pads towards the disc. The force applied is directly the force you put on the levers, which causes more hand fatigue and gives a harsher braking feel, since you have to squeeze harder to brake. With a hydraulic system, braking is excellent and braking power is high with less physical effort and less hand fatigue, and braking control and feel are much easier to manage.

Mechanical brakes are easier to install, since you only need to fit and tension housings and cables as with conventional brakes. Maintenance is also simpler, as it just means replacing worn pads, cables and housings. Hydraulic brakes, by contrast, are more complicated to install: being a hydraulic system, it has to account for possible fluid loss, and there are more rubber seals to prevent leaks. Maintenance is also more complex because of the system itself, as the hydraulic circuit needs bleeding from time to time to remove any air that has got in
If you liked this article and its video, we have a video on our channel where we ANSWER more than 10 QUESTIONS about DISC BRAKES
WE INVITE YOU TO WATCH IT
YOU MIGHT ALSO BE INTERESTED IN:
——–
WANT HELP FROM THE BEST MECHANICS?
Our WORKSHOP is a SHIMANO SERVICE CENTER in the centre of BARCELONA. How can we help you?
HOW DOES A BIKE DISC BRAKE WORK?
HOW do you STOP bike DISC BRAKES from SQUEALING?
Rather have us take a look? At our bike workshop in Barcelona, a Shimano Service Center, we check your brakes, replace pads and rotors and get your braking spot on. Drop by the shop (Carrer València 337) or get in touch.




